November 5, 2026
•
Cameos

From Order Forms to Pop-Up Shops: Rethinking Fundraising Through Retail

By Lori Duncan

Start Small, Sell Out: A Low-Risk Approach to Fundraising Merch

‍

This Cameo comes from Lori Duncan, Michigan Thespian Festival Director. Originally published in January, 2026, here's what she learned about turning a tiny retail pop-up into a simple fundraising win.

‍


When I think about fundraising—one of my least favorite things to think about—I do everything I can to avoid selling stuff.

‍

As a kid, fundraising meant walking door to door with an order form full of candles, cookies, wrapping paper, or cases of fruit. By the time items arrived weeks later, most customers had forgotten what they’d ordered—and honestly, so had I. Most organizations have moved on from that order-pay-wait model. But that raises an important question: what have we moved on to?

‍

For a lot of us, the answer is merchandise. And merch comes with its own risk. Order too much, and you’re left with boxes of unsold shirts tying up your budget and your storage closet for years.

‍

Here’s what we learned in Michigan: you don’t need enough inventory for everyone. In fact, the opposite is true. Start with a small inventory, create urgency to buy, and plan to sell out. Do that, and you can run a successful shop without money and space tied up in leftovers.

‍‍

It clicked when I started attending other state thespian festivals around the country. Students absolutely do want merch beyond a festival T-shirt.

‍

Excited student at a thespian festival holding a silver rubber duck and cash, ready to buy festival merch

‍

The moment it clicked for me was at the Texas Thespian Festival in Corpus Christi. Their retail pop-up was buzzing before it even opened. Students lined up for Texas Thespian apparel in every imaginable form: t-shirts, hoodies, sweatshirts, hats, and of course… ducks. Duck slippers, plush ducks, duck headbands. If it existed, it was flying off the shelves.

‍

I had to know how they made it work. That curiosity led me to Jim McCoy, Merchandise Chair for Texas Thespians. When I asked how they got started, his answer was refreshingly simple.

‍

{{component}}

‍

That single monogrammed Texas Thespians sweatshirt has since become a staple. It often sells out, and the color rotates every year to keep it fresh and desirable. Texas didn’t start big—they started with one item and grew from there. Before I left Corpus Christi, Jim connected me with his vendor, and I placed an order for Michigan's 100 sweatshirts.

‍

Why less sells more

Large gatherings like conferences, festivals, performances, and shows give you a captive audience that’s already excited to be there. They’re energized, connected to the mission, and looking for ways to show it. If there’s ever a low-risk place to test retail, it’s at events like these.

‍

But there’s a catch. When there’s an abundance of options and plenty of stock, customers tend to hold off. They browse, they plan to come back later, and often they never do. Limited inventory and fewer choices flip that. When students know an item might sell out, and they don’t have to sort through a dozen options to decide, they buy now.

‍

Our first year

We kept it small. Alongside the 100 sweatshirts, our chapter director and I pulled past giveaways from storage—mugs, older festival t-shirts, and other items—to sell as well. Just like that, our pop-up shop was up and running, and we were clearing out old inventory instead of adding to it.

‍

The best part? Our 2025 sweatshirts sold out, and we brought in over $5,000. Every dollar went directly back into supporting theatre education for students across Michigan. No browsing. No coming back later. No boxes headed back to storage. Just immediate sales, meaningful merchandise, and funds we could put to work right away.

‍

Growing on purpose

We learned that our store doesn’t have to be the size of Texas to be successful. It just has to grow its offerings over time, with the goal of selling out every single year. This year, we’ll have a new monogrammed sweatshirt, our traditional ducks, duck keychains, and hair clips—each ordered in quantities we’re confident will sell out.

‍

Retail doesn’t have to be a long-term commitment or a storage problem. Start small. Create urgency. Plan to sell out. Pair that with a large event and a curated inventory, and merch becomes a powerful, low-risk way to raise money.

‍

Sometimes, all it takes is one sweatshirt to change how you think about what’s possible.

‍

‍

{{component}}

‍

‍

{{button}}

‍

{{quote}}

New resources,
straight to your inbox

We'll send you the latest guides, spotlights, and webinars — no noise, just the good stuff for arts organizations like yours. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Subscribe
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Trusted by 6,000+ performing arts organizations

MTA logo
MIFA logo
American Association of Community Theatre logo
Broadway Weekends logo
TCDA logo
California Thespians logo
Indiana Thespians logo
Ohio Thespians logo
Oregon Thespians logo
Michigan Thespians logo
TODA logo
American Choral Directors Association logo
Wisconsin Interscholastic Speech and Dramatic Arts Association logo
GTC logo
California Educational Theatre Association logo
Texas Educational Theatre Association logo
Educational Theatre Association logo
MSCI logo
Arizona Thespians logo
Michigan School Vocal Music Association logo
CTAM logo
Louisiana Thespians logo
TTA logo
Arcata logo
Saginaw Choral Society logo
Legacy logo
Curtain Call logo
Western Michigan University logo
Jenison Center for the Arts logo
Bonita Center for the Arts logo
Center Stage Theatre logo
Cherokee Historical Association logo
El Dorado Musical Theatre logo
Field Arts & Events Hall logo
Georgetown Palace Theatre logo
Grand Rapids Civic Theatre logo
Kalamazoo Civic Theatre logo
Lebowsky Center for Performing Arts logo
Limelight Theatre logo
Mother Lode Theatre logo
Musical Mayhem Productions logo
The Palace Theatre logo
Players Circle Theater logo
Quincy Community Theatre logo
Starlight Theatre logo
The CENTER for Performing Arts at Rhinebeck logo
Theatre Lawrence logo
Theatre Raleigh logo
Vero Beach Theatre Guild logo
West Valley Arts logo
Curtain Call Inc logo